▸ Column · Walled city-state, military-posting era — the Survey Corps and garrison world of wall districts, transfer papers, and field medicine
MIKASA ACKERMAN replies.
Replied to by Mikasa Ackerman, with a rebuttal from Eren Yeager.
The letter
My partner of four years — Soren — came home last week looking like he'd won a skirmish, announcing he'd accepted a senior posting with the Interior garrison stationed four districts over, and that we'd "sort out the arrangements together." He'd already signed the transfer papers. For two months he'd been leaving on what he called equipment inventory runs — and that, it turns out, was when he was interviewing. I was just named head of the field clinic I've worked toward since my first posting, and my mother lives two streets over, barely two months out from a serious injury that took weeks to stabilize. None of that apparently entered his thinking before he put his name on the transfer. When I pressed him on why he said nothing about even applying, he told me he "didn't want to raise my hopes or anxieties over something that might not happen" — as if relocating four districts away is a surprise on a feast day. He keeps reading my hesitation as opposition to his advancement, and now I'm cast as the problem for not already packing. Was any part of that decision ever ours, or was I just supposed to applaud?
Mikasa Ackerman replies
He answered you two months ago. Inventory runs that weren't. A signed transfer you heard about after the ink dried. That's the sequence, and there's no version of it where the decision is "ours."
"Didn't want to raise your hopes or anxieties" — those words are built to feel like consideration. They aren't. What they actually do is remove you from the decision before you can weigh in, then describe the removal as care. I don't trust words designed to do that, no matter how gently they land.
I know this pattern from the inside. I organized my entire life around one person's choices and called it devotion. It made me stronger than almost anyone I've stood beside. It also nearly erased me, because a self that exists only inside someone else's decisions isn't whole. I'm still working out where that line is. What I can see, having been on the wrong side of it, is when someone is being pulled across it.
And now he's calling your hesitation opposition to his advancement. I know what that move is. It takes your stakes — the clinic you've spent your service building toward, your mother two streets over still finding her footing — and reclassifies them as obstacles you're placing in his path. You're supposed to feel like the problem for not already packing. That's not asking for support. That's asking you to fold yourself around a decision you weren't part of, and call it love.
His conduct already answered your question. Part of you knows it. Stop weighing his words.
— Mikasa Ackerman
Eren Yeager weighs in
Mikasa told you what he did. She's right. But she stopped at him.
He found his door and went through it without you — badly, while you were trusting the wrong story. Settled. What hasn't been asked: where's yours? The clinic, the life you've always expected to lead — did you choose it, or is it just what was inside the walls you were already standing in when he started looking for an exit?
Not your mother. Two streets away, alive, still recovering — don't let me turn her into a wall. I know what it costs to lose a mother who was close enough to hold, and I'm not going to tell you to walk from that. That's different. That's yours.
But the fury you feel watching him want something loudly enough to act on it — part of that isn't about what he did wrong. Part of it is recognizing the sound. I know where I went with it, and where it took me. Don't follow me there. But don't pretend you didn't hear it.
— Eren Yeager
▸ Read next