▸ Column · Modern grounded Gotham — a new mother in a brownstone, the cat burglar and the Dark Knight reading her mail
CATWOMAN replies.
The letter
My husband Marco's mother, Renata, flew into Gotham three days after our son Theo was born and that was six weeks ago. She has not left. She rearranged my whole kitchen "to find things faster," calls Theo "my baby" in every breath, and last Tuesday I came out of the shower to two aunts I'd never met cooing over him in my living room — nobody asked me. Worse: she sleeps on a cot she hauled into the nursery, and now she gets to Theo when he cries at night before I can even sit up to feed him. When I told Marco, he said she's just excited, she lives four states away, give her grace. I do understand that. But I feel like a guest in my own home and I'm starting to resent all three of them. How do I set a real departure date without it becoming the fight Marco and I are still having when Theo starts kindergarten?
Catwoman replies
Sugar, let's find the lock before we pick it. It isn't Renata. Renata's just a houseguest who figured out nobody in that brownstone would tell her no, so she annexed your kitchen, your living room, and — this is the part that has claws in you — your son at two in the morning. The real lock is Marco. Every road out of this runs through a man who keeps purring "give her grace," and grace, in this house, means you keep folding.
So stop knocking on that door. You keep waiting for permission, and permission is just a lock somebody else holds the key to. It's your home. Your baby. Cut your own key. Tonight the cot comes out of the nursery — that's your room, take it back first, because the night feeds are where she's quietly becoming his mother instead of you. Then you pick the date. Not Marco, not Renata. You. Book her flight yourself, send the confirmation, smile while you do it.
I don't blow up marriages. But I've never once gotten safe and free in the same night, and you've been choosing everyone's comfort but yours. Choose yours. You'll still love them in the morning.
— Catwoman
Batman weighs in
Selina would have you cut the key alone. Wrong. Do that and the marriage is the undefended flank — Renata leaves, the resentment stays, and Marco never learns the perimeter was his to hold.
The breach is your husband. He must be the one who tells his mother the date. In writing. Return flight booked, confirmed, non-negotiable. The nursery is reclaimed first — that is where the line already broke.
Alfred knew when to step back from a grieving boy. Love that cannot give room isn't love. It's occupation.
Make Marco swear to the date. Then watch whether he keeps it.
— Batman
▸ Read next