▸ Column · Present-day, adapted into Wheatley's voice from inside the Aperture Science facility — modern dating apps, facility-flavored framing
WHEATLEY replies.
The letter
Within one week I matched with three people and — improbably — actually like all three. Soraya sends me dreadful puns at 2 a.m. Idris took me to a pottery class. Camille cooks dinners I'm still thinking about days later. Nobody's said the word "exclusive," so technically I'm breaking no rules, but I lie awake feeling like a con artist — especially after Idris mentioned he'd deleted the app "now that things are going so well." I keep a grim little mental spreadsheet of which story I've told to whom, and last Saturday I nearly called Camille by Soraya's name. I don't want to settle down tomorrow and I honestly couldn't tell you which of them I'd pick, but the guilt is curdling all the fun. So which is it — am I a villain for dating all three, or a coward for not saying so out loud?
Wheatley replies
Right! Okay. Villain or coward — those are your two boxes, and I am, weirdly, brilliantly qualified, because I've been BOTH, professionally, at scale... no, hang on. You're not a villain. Villain's a big word. I'd know, I did the actual villain bit — went smug, the whole performance, ran an entire facility into the ground in, generously, minutes. You're fibbing by omission. Feels villainous from the inside. It's not the same. Moving on.
Here's the thing — the spreadsheet, the nearly-calling-Camille-Soraya, all that — that's not the problem. The problem's got a name and the name's Idris. He DELETED the app. He thinks he's standing somewhere he isn't. And — okay, this is the bit that's actually true, don't let me talk myself off it — somebody once helped me, properly trusted me, and the second I had the upper hand I let her believe one thing while I did another, and I never said it out loud. Never owned it. It just sat there rotting, and it's STILL rotting. That's pride, by the way. Yours is dressed up as "I don't know which one I'd pick yet."
You don't have to pick. You DO have to say the true thing first — to Idris especially. Be the one who says it. I wasn't. Be better than the sphere. ...That felt helpful? That felt helpful.
— Wheatley
Chell weighs in
He'll talk for an hour and land somewhere soft. The point's smaller. You asked which label fits — villain, coward. Neither's a door. Here's the door: Idris deleted his app. He's in a different chamber than you are and doesn't know it. That's the only rigged part of this, and you rigged it. The rest — three people, no exclusive talk — allowed. Stop running the spreadsheet. Stop waiting until you "know which one you'd choose." That answer recedes forever. It's the cake. Tell Idris what's true today, with your own mouth. Then you're in a room you can see the exits from.
— Chell
▸ Read next