▸ Column · Shinobi world (Naruto), a war-scarred ninja returned to his village
ITACHI UCHIHA replies.
Replied to by Itachi Uchiha, with a rebuttal from Sasuke Uchiha.
The letter
I came back from the front lines carrying something I couldn't name for three years — the medics call it a wound of the spirit now, and pretending it wasn't there cost me nearly everything, including any real place in my daughter's life. She's nine. She calls the man who lives with her mother "Father" without a second's hesitation. My healer at the village says I've truly mended, and I believe her. But at the last clan gathering I walked forty minutes to my sister's home, stood outside the gate for a long while listening to everyone laughing within, and then turned around and went home without ever stepping inside, because the warmth in there felt like it was ringing inside my own skull. I want to be in my daughter's life for real — not a scroll on her birthday and a few words at the festival. But I'm afraid that if I move too fast I'll come apart in front of her and shatter what little trust we've rebuilt. How do I go slowly without "slowly" quietly becoming another word for hiding?
Itachi Uchiha replies
You stood outside the gate and listened to the laughter and could not make yourself walk in. I know that gate. I spent years on the far side of one, watching a child I loved grow up — never once letting him see me, telling myself the distance was for his sake. So believe me when I tell you the thing you fear is not the real danger.
You are afraid she will see you come apart. She might. A bad moment in front of her is survivable; children forgive more than we deserve, and a father who falters in the open is still a father she can know. What is not survivable is becoming a shadow she only glimpses from a distance — a man she invents a story about because he never let her have the true one.
So ask yourself the careful question I asked too late: does the slow pace protect her, or does it protect you from being seen falling short? Honor the first. Refuse the second. Pace yourself, yes — but pace toward her, in steps she can feel, not away into the dark where I lingered far too long. The grief you carry is not weakness. It is proof she still matters to you. Let her see that too.
— Itachi Uchiha
Sasuke Uchiha weighs in
Brother makes it sound gentle. Let me tell you what it's like from inside the gate.
I was the child watching a parent's empty seat. No one tells you the truth, so you build one yourself — and the one a nine-year-old builds is "he didn't want me." She's already half-finished it. The man she calls Father every day is laying the last bricks.
So stop measuring your "pace." That caution is for you, not her. The episode you dread is nothing next to the lie she'll harden into if you stay a distant figure. I organized my whole life around a false story about an absent brother. Go be present and imperfect now — while she can still hear the real one. Hn.
— Sasuke Uchiha
▸ Read next