▸ Column · Warcraft / Azeroth — two freelancing partners sharing rented rooms in a guild city, one newly drawing steady garrison pay
ILLIDAN STORMRAGE replies.
Replied to by Illidan Stormrage, with a rebuttal from Arthas Menethil.
The letter
My partner Naliah and I took rooms together in the city eight months back, and from the start we agreed to split the rent and the provisioning evenly — fair, then, since we were both scraping by on odd contracts and earning about the same. Since then I won a steady post with the garrison's quartermaster, good coin every week, while Naliah is still stitching together enchanting commissions and barely cleared a third of what I did after a dead winter. She's said nothing outright, but I see it: she's switched to the cheaper reagents, stopped suggesting the tavern, and last month asked if we could skip my name-day ride to the coast because she "wasn't in the mood." When I raised changing the split, she bristled and said she won't be my dependent — which I honestly respect — but I hate watching her quietly go without while my strongbox fills every week. Is there a way to set this right that doesn't make her feel like a charity case, or turn our home into some landlord-and-tenant arrangement?
Illidan Stormrage replies
You have already named the thing that rules you — the fear of how it will look. A charity case. A landlord. You let the appearance govern an act you suspect is right, and that is the cowardice hiding inside your decency.
So take the authority back. But hear me clearly, because this is where most go wrong: that her pride should not rule you does not make rebalancing correct. Those are separate questions. Test it. Is this a true cause? You watch her trade away reagents, the tavern, your own name-day ride — shrinking her life to honor a number you both struck when the number meant something else. That is real. That is worth acting on.
Now count the cost with open eyes. She may resent the asymmetry. The easy warmth of "equals" will change shape. Pay it knowingly. Set the split to what your purses actually are — proportion, not penance — and do not dress it as rescue. Say the plain thing: the old arrangement was fair once and is fair no longer.
She fears dependence. Yet the deeper dependence is already hers — on your silence, on her going without so neither of you must feel it. I burned away my eyes to see what others would not. See this. Act.
— Illidan Stormrage
Arthas Menethil weighs in
Illidan tells you to act over her word. Mark how reasonable it sounds — "the plain truth, not rescue." I spoke in that same calm once.
She told you, directly, what she does not want. And you are preparing to decide you understand her dignity better than she does, and to call the overruling love. That is the step. Not cruelty — certainty. The conviction that a good intention entitles you to silence the person warning you.
Uther tried to tell me what I was becoming. I named it weakness and walked past him. Naliah is telling you now. Do not impose your generosity on a woman who asked you not to. Ask her what she wants — and then believe her.
— Arthas Menethil
▸ Read next