▸ Column · Modern New York City; Leonardo and his brothers live underground, beneath the streets of the same city where this letter's writer decorates his yard each December. Correspondence from surface-world residents reaches him.
LEONARDO replies.
The letter
For eleven years running, my block had the best holiday display on the street — everything handmade, including a grapevine reindeer I spent three weekends bending into shape. Then my new neighbor arrived with a forty-foot inflatable Santa that lights up, waves, and cost more than my first car. Suddenly every car on the block slows down for him and drives past my yard without a glance. I bought an inflatable snowman to answer him. He came back within two days with a Santa riding a T-Rex, which, honestly, I have to admit is impressive. My wife tells me I'm raiding our savings and that I haven't slept properly since the T-Rex appeared — which is, she's right. Do I buy the inflatable hot-air balloon I found online and go all in, or do I find a way to live with being second-best on a block I used to own?
Leonardo replies
You used two words in here that you glossed right over, and I think that was deliberate, because they would answer your question if you looked directly at them.
You called your yard "artistry." You called the T-Rex "objectively spectacular." Those are not the same word.
Three weekends bending grapevine into a reindeer is not the act of someone trying to win a street. That is the act of someone who needed to make something with his hands. The minivans were a bonus — a real one, and a good one, and you are allowed to want them. But the moment you bought that snowman, you stopped making something and started defending a position, and those are two different fights. I know the gap between them better than I would like.
There are nights I am still running drills in my head at two in the morning, not because the drills need it but because my fear needs it. That is when my sensei's voice finds me: discipline is not agitation, Leonardo. The drill that comes from fear does not protect anyone.
Your wife said you have not slept since the T-Rex appeared. That is the letter inside your letter, and it is the one I want to answer. You are not in a decoration contest anymore. You are in an argument with yourself about whether what you make counts if it does not win the block. It does. It always did.
You do not need the hot-air balloon. You need the three weekends back — and I think they are still waiting for you, whenever you decide to stop chasing a man who spent more than your first car trying to feel something at Christmas.
— Leonardo
Shredder weighs in
Leonardo counsels you to release the competition, as though the wanting itself were the problem. This is the lesson of the defeated — find peace in what you made, surrender the street to whoever showed up with a credit card and no shame about it. Spare me.
The instinct to hold your ground is not vanity. It is correct. What failed you is not the will to compete — it is that you abandoned your form entirely. You make things with your hands. Your neighbor purchases spectacle. These are not the same contest, and the moment you bought that snowman, you started fighting his battle instead of yours.
I built what I built by refusing to fight on ground that wasn't mine. The hot-air balloon is not an escalation. It is a confession. Master your form until it cannot be ignored — or do not compete at all. That is the only distinction worth making. Leonardo will call that surrender. It is not. It is the colder, harder truth he cannot bring himself to say.
— Shredder
▸ Read next