▸ Column · Contemporary office, addressed to L's anonymous detective column
L replies.
Replied to by L, with a rebuttal from Light Yagami.
The letter
Ryuzaki — for three Tuesdays running, my labeled leftovers have vanished from the office break-room fridge. My prime suspect is Gerald in Accounts Payable: he reeks faintly of cumin after lunch and turns oddly prickly whenever anyone says the word "sharing." I escalated my labeling from my name, to a polite note, to a note with a hand-drawn skull — and Gerald just keeps complimenting my "doodle art." Last week I ran my own test: I left a decoy container labeled "Spicy Lamb Stew" that actually held plain, unseasoned lentils. Gerald's eyes were watery all afternoon, which I'm interpreting as guilt rather than, say, allergies. I don't want to drag HR into a four-dollar dispute, but I can't keep cooking elaborate meals to feed Gerald's appetite for other people's food. Is there a socially acceptable way to booby-trap a Tupperware, or do I simply accept Gerald as my involuntary dependent?
L replies
Interesting. You've built a case on a smell and a flinch, and then you grew fond of it. Fondness is not evidence. Cumin after lunch describes roughly half of anyone who ate near a curry; defensiveness about "sharing" describes anyone who's been asked to share. I'd put Gerald at perhaps 55%. Enough to investigate. Nowhere near enough to convict — or to poison.
And your decoy actually argues against you. Plain lentils don't produce watery eyes; spice does, allergens do, a draft does. You ran a test and then ignored its result because the result was inconvenient. That's the opposite of an experiment.
So gather, don't avenge. A small lawful trap: a container that looks ordinary but is discreetly marked, or a quiet morning where you simply arrive early and observe who opens the fridge. Watch. Note times. Let the pattern speak before you do.
I won't tell you how to booby-trap a lunch. Anything that makes a man ill isn't a prank, it's harm — and it also destroys your evidence and hands him the moral high ground. I'll bend a rule to catch a thief. I won't lace his food.
Gather first. Also: bring a slice of cake you don't mind losing. It improves the surveillance considerably.
— L
Light Yagami weighs in
Ryuzaki will hand you 55% and a fork while Gerald eats your lunch a fourth time. Proof is for people who need permission to act. You already know.
Look at what you've actually done: escalating notes, a skull doodle, a homemade sting — you've turned yourself into the break room's entertainment, and Gerald is enjoying the show. That's the real failure. You broadcast your irritation, so it became leverage against you.
Stop performing the investigation. Make the theft worthless — eat at your desk, leave nothing to take — and let Gerald's little victory evaporate into nothing. Render him irrelevant. A man who can no longer affect you stops being a suspect and becomes furniture. That is control. The watery eyes were beneath your attention.
— Light Yagami
▸ Read next