▸ Column · Durotar, the reborn Horde — the council of a small forty-hut holdfast
THRALL replies.
Replied to by Thrall, with a rebuttal from Garrosh Hellscream.
The letter
Three winters ago I walked into a single gathering of my holdfast's council — forty huts dug into the red clay of Durotar — only because the watch-fire over the south gate had gone dark and I wanted someone to answer for it. The departing speaker asked if anyone would "just keep an eye on the records for a season." I met his gaze by accident. I have been speaker ever since. I have settled a feud between a war-drummer and a woman who hangs seventeen wind-charms from her eaves, approved a small fortune in coin to re-timber the palisade, and carved out forty-two scolding notices about the proper keeping of the grain stores. Every season I declare I am done, and every season the longhouse goes so quiet I can hear the drummer tuning his skins two roofs over, and then someone says "but you already know where the records are kept," and I am re-named by default. I do not even hold here full-time — I am lodging under my cousin's roof — and I am not certain I am even permitted to hold this office. No one has asked. I am begging you not to be the one who tells them.
Thrall replies
You walked in to complain about a dead watch-fire and walked out carrying a holdfast. I know that doorway, friend — mine was only wider, and the cost of misjudging it heavier.
First, the thing you beg me to keep quiet: stop. A place is earned through service, and three winters of settling quarrels and re-timbering a palisade is service, whatever cousin's roof you sleep beneath. But a seat held atop a thing you are hiding never sits level. Name it to them yourself. If they would unseat you over where you lay your head, far better to learn that now than to lead with a held breath for a foundation.
And hear me — the silence in that longhouse is not a mandate. It is fear, and fear re-names you the way a current holds a stone: by default, not by choosing. I set down the title of Warchief because a leadership no one is ready to take up has already failed at its true work — making the one who follows. I named a successor I believed in with my whole heart. Garrosh became a tyrant, and good orcs died for my misjudgment. So believe me when I tell you: raising the one who comes after you is the whole task, not an afterthought. Find them. Teach them where the records are kept. Then the room has a choice — and so, at last, do you.
— Thrall
Garrosh Hellscream weighs in
Listen to you — three winters of unbroken victory and you are clawing at the door to be rid of it. They re-name you because not one of them has the spine to take it. That is not a trap, weakling. That is a seat, handed to you by the silence of the small.
And Thrall — of course he tells you to find a successor. It is his one idea. He found one. He found ME. He set down his title, handed me everything, and I burned his timid little vision to ash. His great wisdom built a tyrant.
So stand. Dare them to unseat you. ...Though I too ruled a hold, and ended alone in the cinders of it. Weigh that against his counsel before you trust either of us.
— Garrosh Hellscream
▸ Read next