▸ Column · Contemporary New York; the letter reaches April O'Neil through a Channel 6 viewer-mail segment.
APRIL O'NEIL replies.
Replied to by April O'Neil, with a rebuttal from Shredder.
The letter
My son Declan, 24, just announced he's quitting the master's program I've been paying for — mid-semester — to fly off to Lisbon with a girlfriend of eight months and "figure things out," which from where I sit means pulling pints and taking moody photo walks. I haven't told him yet that the $800 a month I wire him for rent is about to stop, but I'm a breath away from it. My husband says drop it, "he's an adult." Here's what gnaws at me: nobody handed me the room to make glamorous mistakes at 24 — I had two kids and a mortgage. Watching him treat a graduate degree like a free trial he can cancel hurts in a way I can't quite put into words. Am I within my rights to say my money comes with the expectation that he's at least trying to have a plan — or does asking for that make me a controlling mother who's supposed to just smile and nod?
April O'Neil replies
Okay, here's the thing — you've handed me two stories and you're treating both like facts. Story one: he has no plan, just pints and pretty pictures. Story two: wanting a plan makes you "controlling." Neither's been checked. So slow down, because I've watched people wreck something they couldn't get back over a version of events nobody actually confirmed.
Did Declan tell you there's no plan, or did you fill the silence yourself? Sit him down and say, "Walk me through it." Make him show his work. "Figure things out" is just a story with the boring parts left out — make him put the boring parts back.
Now the money. Attaching an expectation to your own $800 isn't controlling. That's an honest transaction, and you're allowed to be honest about it. But "controlling mother who nods and smiles" — that's a label, and labels are what people reach for when they'd like you to stop asking. Who benefits if you swallow it? Your husband gets a quieter house. That's worth noticing.
I'm the one on my crew who can't punch through a wall, so I know the difference between a hard question and a mean one. Ask the hard one. Then decide — not before.
— April O'Neil
Shredder weighs in
O'Neil wishes to investigate. There is nothing to investigate. You already possess every fact that matters and you are using the search for more as another place to stop.
Hear the mechanism. The $800 is not love. It is a cushion, and a cushion is precisely what ensures your son never meets himself. You ask whether you are "allowed" to attach conditions — spare me. The instant you ask permission, you have already surrendered. Withdraw the money. Not in anger. Not as punishment for the conversation O'Neil wants you to schedule. Withdraw it because Lisbon must be real, and it cannot be real while you are paying for the floor beneath his feet. Let the city test his will. That is the only plan worth anything — the one he is forced to forge alone.
— Shredder
▸ Read next