▸ Column · Modern-day grounded, Avengers-era contemporary
IRON MAN replies.
The letter
My husband Iolo has been performing the same snooty British butler impression for three straight years — the one he debuted to enormous laughs at our engagement party. He delivers a clipped "Very good, madam" whenever I ask him to unload the dishwasher, bows formally when handing over my coffee, and last week he fielded an entire call from our daughter's preschool teacher fully in character before I managed to grab the phone. The routine landed beautifully in year one. Now Mango, our golden retriever, gets up and quietly leaves the moment Iolo clears his throat to "announce" dinner. I've tried laughing it off, ignoring it entirely, and outright begging — each time, he produces an imaginary monocle and informs me that a gentleman never abandons his post. We have a big family wedding next month, and I am genuinely frightened he'll deliver the toast entirely in character, in front of his extremely serious extended family. How do I get the man I actually married back to the surface?
Iron Man replies
Okay, so here's the thing — and I say this as someone who has never, not once, used humor to dodge a feeling he wasn't ready to deal with, so weigh my authority accordingly — the butler bit isn't a bit anymore. The bit died somewhere around month eight. What Iolo's running now is armor.
I know exactly how this works. Best night of his life, full crowd, enormous laugh, and that laugh got burned into the circuitry. Real life moved in afterward — the dishwasher, the preschool voicemails, the actual ongoing texture of being married — and the only thing that still had that original energy was the bit. So he reaches for it. Not because something's broken. Because it's safe. Safe is comfortable. And a gentleman never abandons his post.
Don't go in trying to kill the joke. You'll lose that fight, and even if you win, you'll have won the wrong thing. Go in and say what's actually true: you miss him when he's in character. Not the punchline — him. Flat, no performance, no tactical framing.
The wedding deadline you're dreading? Use it as an invitation, not a threat. "I want us both to actually be present for this one."
And it's worth asking — was laughing along and letting it go your own version of looking fine? I live in that version. It's remarkably comfortable and completely useless.
— Iron Man
Thanos weighs in
Fascinating. Stark examines three years of steadily compounding avoidance and concludes the problem lives inside the husband's unexamined wound. How consistent of him.
Little one, read what you have actually written: you laughed, you ignored, you begged. Three approaches, each weaker than the last, all of them negotiations with a reality that simply waited you out. Titan made similar negotiations. They were sincere and well-intentioned, and they chose extinction with very clean hands.
Stark prescribes tenderness. That is not wrong, exactly — it is merely insufficient. The imbalance persists because you have never once made clear what its continuation costs. Not as a threat. As a fact. That is the only correction that will hold.
Your husband is not a mystery to be excavated. He is a man whose comfortable performance has gone unchecked for three years because you have kept choosing the softer version of the conversation. Open the actual door.
— Thanos
▸ Read next