▸ Column · Modern grounded comic — Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters, the Headmaster answering staff correspondence
PROFESSOR X replies.
Replied to by Professor X, with a rebuttal from Magneto.
The letter
Professor — I teach in the lower school and have been seeing another instructor here, Marcus, for two years. For the last six months he's taken to lifting my phone the moment I step out of a room: my messages to my sister, my staff channels, all of it. Last week at his parents' supper I came back to find him scrolling a thread between me and a colleague — we were arranging a surprise birthday lunch for HIM, which of course is spoiled now, and which left me feeling like a suspect at my own table. When I raised it on the drive home he said he only looks because I'm "always smiling at the screen," and that if I had nothing to hide I wouldn't object. I don't have anything to hide. But "nothing to hide" and "no claim to privacy" aren't the same sentence, and every time I try to explain the difference it becomes a three-hour argument in which I somehow end up apologizing. Is there a way to truly reach him, or is this one of those things that only looks mendable?
Professor X replies
I am, of all the people you might have written to, the one least entitled to read a mind uninvited — and so I have made it the first law of my life never to do it. Let me tell you why that bears on Marcus. The instant a person reaches into another "for their own good," they have stopped being a partner and become a warden, and no one has ever grown warm under a warden. What Marcus is doing is not closeness. It is control wearing closeness as a coat.
So look beneath it, as I would. A man does not search the one who loves him because he is content; he does it because some fear has him by the throat — of being unchosen, of being the last to know. That fear is real and it deserves your compassion. It does not, however, get to make your boundary for you. You can hold both at once: "I see that you're frightened, and I am not going to surrender my privacy to soothe it."
There is a man I have loved my whole life whom I could not turn from a darker version of this same logic — the conviction that safety requires control. I never reached him. I tell you so you'll know my hope is not cheap. Hold the door. Do not walk through it apologizing.
— Professor X
Magneto weighs in
Charles, you beautiful, tireless man — you've diagnosed his fear and prescribed her patience, and somehow she is still the one holding the door.
Listen to the sentence, my friend. "Nothing to hide." I have heard it before, spoken by men in uniform to people in lines. It is never the language of a frightened lover. It is the language of the watcher establishing that he may watch. Marcus is not afraid; he is claiming territory, and your asker is being managed into apology.
Stop trying to reach him. You cannot explain your way into rights the powerful have decided you don't hold. Change the power instead: the privacy is not negotiable, the phone is not his, and the next search is the last conversation. Leverage, not persuasion. He will respect only what costs him.
— Magneto
▸ Read next